Department of Theatre

Choose Your Own Ending for Tony Award-Winning Murder Mystery Musical at the University of Southern Maine

February 24, 2014


GORHAM, Maine – Audiences will get to choose their own ending next month at the University of Southern Maine (USM) Department of Theatre and School of Music co-production of “The Mystery of Edwin Drood,” a “whodunit” murder mystery musical, in Russell Hall on the USM Gorham campus.

Charles Dickens died before he could finish his extraordinary murder novel, and that is only the beginning of the mystery. Both sinister and hilarious, this Tony Award-winning picks up where Dickens left off. “The Mystery of Edwin Drood” is a comical play-within-a-play, featuring actors at London’s Music Hall Royale in the late 1800s. Each character is an actor who plays a particular role in a show at the music hall.

Throughout the production, the Chairman, a master of ceremonies of sorts, speaks to the audience and explains their responsibility in determining the end of the show. In the second act, Edwin Drood has disappeared, and there are eight suspects who may have contributed to his assumed demise. Along with the murder mystery, there are several intertwined love stories, and the audience also must vote to decide which characters will end up together.

The details of the production are:

  • “The Mystery of Edwin Drood,” show times vary, March 14-23, Russell Hall, USM Gorham campus, 37 College Ave., Gorham; Tickets: $21/$15/$11, call (207) 780-5151 or go to:

“The possibilities are almost endless when you consider the different pairings of romantic interests, along with the selection of the murderer,” said Wil Kilroy, director of the production and USM professor of theatre.

“Another aspect that will change for each performance is the title role, which is double-cast,” Kilroy said. Eileen Hanley and Emily Davis, each USM senior musical theatre majors, will alternate playing Edwin Drood for each performance. 

Along with a distinctive ending for each show, there also will be a unique beginning -- and it starts as soon as audiences enter Russell Hall. The Chairman and Victorian-era costumed characters will be roaming through the crowd and greeting guests as they arrive. The audience interaction doesn’t stop there. “The Mystery of Edwin Drood” was inspired by British pantomime and music hall traditions, in which actors continually interact with the audience and welcome participation, such as hissing at the villain.

“Audience interaction is rampant throughout the show,” said Edward Reichert, the show’s musical director and USM lecturer is musical theatre. “There is one number in particular that really heats things up. Princess Puffer’s rendition of ‘The Wages of Sin’ is not for the faint of heart. Married couples sitting down front: beware!”

Other well known songs include “Moonfall” and “The Writing on the Wall.” Rupert Holmes wrote the book, music and lyrics for  “The Mystery of Edwin Drood,” which debuted on Broadway in 1985 and won five Tony Awards including best musical, best book of a musical and best original score.

Reichert noted that the show’s music “perfectly exemplifies the show’s sassy and saucy flavor.” There will be a five-piece band comprised of USM students majoring in music, and Kellie Moody, USM senior piano performance major, will provide accompaniment and is the associate musical director.

Vanessa Beyland, choreographer for the production, worked with Kilroy, Reichert and the cast to extend the British music hall tradition into song and dance numbers, including “There You Are,” “Don’t Quit While You’re Ahead,” “Off to the Races” and “Both Sides of the Coin.”

“Because the show is a musical within a musical, the dances help bring the audience into the world of the performer and the story being presented,” Beyland said. “There is a lot of playing to the audience, gimmicks and larger-than-life moves and gestures.

“Rehearsals have been a blast,” the choreographer added. “Everyone comes with such energy and enthusiasm, it has inspired me to create very fun and entertaining choreography.” 

While characters continually interact with the audience during the show, there may be a few lucky audience members who will actually be seated within the Music Hall Royale.

“We are not only creating scenic elements that are specific to the play, but we are also creating the fictitious 19th-century Music Hall Royale, where our production is being performed,” said Charles Kading, set designer for the production and USM professor of theatre. “We hope to seat a pair of audience members each night in the Music Hall Royale box seats onstage, flanking the performance area.”

Joan Mather, USM assistant professor of theatre, is managing costume design, and JP Gagnon is creating lighting design.

The USM Department of Theatre and School of Music team up every season to co-produce an opera or musical.

“It’s the best of both worlds,” Kilroy said. “The department of theatre offers expertise in set and lighting design, directing, and original costume designs. The School of Music’s musical theatre students are trained with technique and voice lessons, and their musicians provide accompaniment for the performance. I’m sure the audience will be pleased to hear voices that rival some I’ve heard on Broadway!

“I feel honored to work with students who have this caliber of talent,” Kilroy continued. “It makes my job a joy.” 

Show Times (including the actress who will play Edwin Drood)

7:30 p.m., Friday, March 14 (Emily Davis)
7:30 p.m., Saturday, March 15 (Eileen Hanley)
5 p.m., Sunday, March 16 (Emily Davis)
10 a.m., Tuesday, March 18; high school matinee (Eileen Hanley)
5 p.m., Wednesday, March 19; all seats $10 (Eileen Hanley)
7:30 p.m., Thursday, March 20 (Emily Davis)
7:30 p.m., Friday, March 21 (Eileen Hanley)
7:30 p.m., Saturday, March 22 (Emily Davis)
5 p.m., Sunday, March 23 (Eileen Hanley)


$21, general public; $15, seniors, USM employees and alumni; $11 students.

Call the USM Theatre Box Office at (207) 780-5151 or go to

A special reduced-price matinee at 5 p.m., Wednesday, March 19 offers all tickets at just $10.

A special high school matinee will be presented at 10 a.m., Tuesday, March 18. Reduced ticket pricing is available and reservations are required. High schools should contact the USM Theatre Box Office for more information and reservations.

“The Mystery of Edwin Drood” includes some adult subject matter.

The cast includes (by name, role, year, major, hometown):

Caleb Lacy (Chairman): senior theatre major; Durham
Emily Davis (Edwin Drood): senior musical theatre major; Windham
Eileen Hanley (Edwin Drood):  senior musical theatre major; Peaks Island
Carolyn Glaude (Rosa Budd): senior musical theatre major: Topsham
Matthew West (John Jasper): junior musical theatre major; Farmington
Danielle Lane (Princess Puffer): senior musical theatre major; Caribou
Eric Berry-Sandelin (Reverend Mr. Crisparkle): sophomore musical theatre major; South Portland
Cameron Wright (Neville Landless): sophomore musical theatre major; Ellsworth
Liz Kershenbaum (Helena Landless): junior musical theatre major; North Andover, Mass.
JP Furey (Bazzard): sophomore musical theatre major; South Portland
Matthew LeBerge (Durdles): sophomore music major; South Portland
Taylor Gervais (Deputy): freshman musical theatre major; Harmon
Meghan O'Brian (The Stage Manager): continuing education theatre major; Gray
Rachel Grindle (Ensemble): freshman musical theatre major; Portland
Jonathan Gudroe (Ensemble): sophomore theatre major; Dexter
Jordan Holt (Ensemble):  junior musical theatre major; Plymouth, Mass.
Brianna Housman (Ensemble):  freshman musical theatre major; Searsport
Gregory Judd (Ensemble): senior music education major; Auburn
Alyssa Rojecki (Ensemble): senior theatre major; Gorham
Ali Sarnacchiaro (Ensemble): freshman musical theatre major; Saugus, Mass.
Caleb Streadwick (Ensemble): freshman theatre major; Whitehall, Mont.